Skip to content

Rock ‘n’ Roll King vs Calypso King (1956-1957)

 

By Ger Rijff / Bob Pakes
 
 

Elvis and Harry TOP Nuevo ZigZag (Chile)When HARRY BELAFONTE hit it big with such hits as Island In The Sun, Banana Boat Song and especially his million selling album Calypso, he became RCA Victor’s best selling act. Belafonte (born in 1927) was crowned CALYPSO KING.
 
Around the same time America went Calypso mad, another music genre quickly grew out of proportion: Rock ‘n’ Roll.
ELVIS PRESLEY (also under contract at RCA) became known as the KING OF ROCK ‘N’ ROLL.
The media of course, were responsible for crowning both Elvis and Belafonte ‘Kings’ of their respective genres.
 
Let’s take a look at the impact of Harry Belafonte and his Calypso music on Elvis’ popularity during his breakthrough years of 1956 and 1957.

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

16 magazine (July 1957)For a year, or even less, the almighty media had hoped the Calypso Dance would wipe the floor with the nasty Rock ‘n’ Roll craze. Of course it didn’t. Belafonte was loved for the most part by adults while Hep Cats couldn’t be bothered with the Caribbean Calypso sounds favoured by their parents.
 
 
The magazine publication from the first half of 1957 simply titled 16, with both Elvis Presley and Harry Belafonte on the cover, is undoubtly one of the rarest Teen mags ever published.
 
 
Some magazine editors smelled money and teamed the then very popular Belafonte up with Elvis in two of their Teen titles. Both of these magazines were published by the same house that had previously done ELVIS AND JIMMY and ELVIS SPEAKS back in 1956.
 
Combining Elvis and Belafonte turned out to be a big failure since Teen mags were bought mainly by young white girls and Harry Belafonte didn’t exactly fit their taste. Many copies of both titles went back unsold to the publishing company in New York shortly after they’d seen distribution at newsstands all over the USA. Because sales were so poor back then, very few copies of both titles have survived into this day and age.

 

TOMMY SANDS vs. BELAFONTE and ELVIS (1957)TOMMY SANDS vs. BELAFONTE and ELVIS is the 2nd one shot title that is near impossible to find in auction these days.
 
As if one battle that never really was a battle wasn’t enough, one-hit-wonder Tommy Sands got thrown into the ring as well. According to the publishers, Tommy was ready to take on (not just one but) both leading artists in their respective genres. What???
 
 
TOMMY SANDS vs. BELAFONTE and ELVIS (1957) page

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

Poplar Tunes (Memphis 1957) 6Here we have some very interesting photos of Elvis visiting POPLAR TUNES in Memphis, in early 1957.
 
By looking at these pictures one can tell how popular Harry Belafonte actually was: his face/records appear in nearly all of the photos taken that day at Poplar, even though of course Elvis was Memphis’ local hero.
 
 
PHOTO TO THE LEFT:
Elvis seems to be looking at one (of three) of Belafonte’s albums on the top shelf.
Elvis’ own two LP’s can be seen to the right of the photo.

 

Poplar Tunes (Memphis 1957) 2PHOTO TO THE RIGHT:
Apart from the cool Elvis director’s chair we can spot a huge stock of Belafonte 45’s that are brought to the attention by the BELAFONTE 89¢ record-divider.
 
 
PHOTO BELOW:
There is no Belafonte in this lucky fan’s photo, but to the right we can spot Memphis DJ Dewey Phillips while we see Elvis’ girlfriend Barbara Hearn to the left.
 
Poplar Tunes (Memphis 1957) 4
 
 
PHOTOS BELOW:
In these two images Elvis is in the company of Dewey Phillips and record shop owner Joe Cuoghi. In front of these gentlemen we see an RCA promo display for An Evening With Belafonte.
The photo to the right is quite wellknown (though it is usually heavily cropped with the Belafonte display being photoshopped out of the image). But the photo to the left has very rarely been seen.

 

Poplar Tunes (Memphis 1957) 5 Poplar Tunes (Memphis 1957) 3

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

Cocktail Di Successi N. 5 (A10V 0109, Italy, 1957, 10 inch)Any vintage record covers that feature both Presley and Belafonte?
Well, yes! The Rock King and the Calypso King have been brought together by RCA ITALY on two (nowadays very rare) Various Artists albums:
 
 
COCKTAIL DI SUCCESSI N. 5
(1957 / A10V 0109)
 
Five RCA recording stars have been collected on this album, with two songs by each artist.

 

Cocktail Di Successi N. 8 (Italy, 1958)COCKTAIL DI SUCCESSI N. 8
(1958 / LPM 10003)
 
This time we have 12 RCA recording stars singing one song each on this album.

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

Jailhouse Rock (1957) screenshotIn the movie JAILHOUSE ROCK (1957), many RCA recording stars pop up on the posters on the wall to the right of the studio while Vince is going through Treat Me Nice and Don’t Leave Me Now.
 
Next to Pery Como, Eddie Fisher, Lena Horne and Dinah Shore we (of course!) see Harry Belafonte’s face on one of the most prominent spots on the wall.
 
During the close-up shots of Treat Me Nice (taken with a different set-up) a 2nd image of Belafonte (actually the cover of An Evening With Belafonte) can be seen on the wall behind Elvis.

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

Catalog october 1959Here we have three RCA VICTOR CATALOGS that all carry an album by Elvis as well as Belafonte on the cover.
 
The catalog below to the left is from January 1957.
The one next to that is from August 1957.
And the catalog to the right is from October 1959.

 

Catalog january 1957 Catalog august 1957

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

Okay. So who actually was ‘King Of The Charts’?

Was it Elvis, or Harry?

Let’s take a look at the statistics, as supplied by BILLBOARD Magazine!

 
 
 

Billboard, March 24, 1956

March 24, 1956 | ‘Belafonte’

LPM-1150 (1956)

 

Billboard, April 28, 1956

April 28, 1956 | ‘Belafonte’

BELAFONTE (Harry’s second LP) went to Nr. 1 on March 24.
It remained Nr. 1 for six weeks.
 
ELVIS PRESLEY (Elvis’ first LP) had moved to the Nr. 2 position by April 28.
 
One week later ELVIS PRESLEY will take over the Nr. 1 spot from BELAFONTE.
(see next entry)
 
ELVIS PRESLEY remained Nr. 1 for ten weeks.

 

Billboard, May 5, 1956

May 5, 1956 | ‘Elvis Presley’

LPM-1254 (1956)

 

Billboard, September 8, 1956

September 8, 1956 | ‘Calypso’

LPM-1248 (1956)

 

Billboard, October 20, 1956

October 20, 1956 | ‘Calypso’

CALYPSO (Harry’s third LP) went to Nr. 1 on September 8.
The album remained in the Nr. 1 spot for four weeks.
 
After losing the topspot for a total of two weeks (to the soundtracks of The King And I and The Eddy Duchin Story), CALYPSO regained the Nr. 1 position for another seven weeks on october 20.

 

Billboard, December 1, 1956

December 1, 1956 | ‘Calypso’

By December, CALYPSO had become the biggest selling album of the year, and it was also the first ever LP in history to sell over one million copies.
 
ELVIS (Elvis’ second LP) had moved to the Nr. 2 position on December 1.
 
One week later ELVIS will take over the Nr. 1 spot from CALYPSO.
(see next entry)
 
ELVIS remained Nr. 1 for five weeks.

 

Billboard, December 8, 1956

December 8, 1956 | ‘Elvis’

LPM-1382 (1956)

 

Billboard, January 12, 1957

January 12, 1957 | ‘Calypso’

So, twice in a row Elvis Presley was responsible for taking over the Nr. 1 position from Harry Belafonte. But it turned out that the success of CALYPSO was far from over, in fact, it had only just begun!
 
On January 12 CALYPSO moved ELVIS back to the Nr. 2 position, regaining the top spot for a third time, and this time the album remained in the Nr. 1 position for another 20 weeks.

 

Billboard, May 20, 1957

May 20, 1957 | ‘Calypso’

CALYPSO stayed on top of the Billboard Album chart until May 20.
 
The LP had been the Nr. 1 album in the USA for an incredible total of 31 weeks.
 
In the same week, AN EVENING WITH BELAFONTE (Harry’s fourth LP), released while Calypso was still in the Nr. 1 position, dropped two places from 3 to 5.
 
Harry Belafonte had enjoyed a tremendous run on the charts with his two consecutive Nr. 1 hit albums, but he would not score a Nr. 1 album again during the course of his career.
 
And this is really where ‘the battle’ for the Top Spot between Rock ‘n’ Roll (Presley) and Calypso (Belafonte) ended.

 
 
 
 
 

Harry Elvis 1957

So, what’s the verdict?

Who was the King Of The Charts?

Before we come to a conclusion, let’s take the album releases of 1957 into account that did not exactly battle it out with each other on the charts, but that have played a significant role nonetheless during the Calypso and Rock ‘n’ Roll crazes when it comes to album sales and chart listings.

 
 
 
 
 

LPM-1505 (1957) LPM-1402 (1957)Harry Belafonte released two albums in 1957:

‘An Evening With Belafonte’

This LP would not be able to equal the succes of its two predecessors, even though it eventually reached the Nr. 2 position.

‘Belafonte Sings Of The Caribbean’

Harry’s fifth album went to Nr. 3 on the Billboard chart.

 

LOC-1035 (1957) LPM-1515 (1957)Elvis also released two albums in 1957:

‘Loving You’

Elvis’ third album would also become his third Nr. 1.

‘Elvis’ Christmas Album’

Album number four was Elvis’ fourth consecutive Nr. 1.
 
Elvis’ Christmas Album spent 4 weeks in the top spot (2 of which were in 1958) and it would be Elvis’ last Nr. 1 album until December 1960 (when G.I. Blues reached the top of the chart.)

 
 
 
 
 

Elvis and Liz 1957 Harry and Shari 1957

The facts:

During 1956 and 1957, Elvis and Harry both released 4 albums.
Two of Harry’s albums went to Nr. 1, spending a total of 37 WEEKS (6 + 31) in the top spot.
All four of Elvis’ albums reached the top of the chart but they ‘only’ totaled 27 WEEKS (5 + 10 + 10 + 2) in the Nr. 1 spot.
 
Next to his Nr. 1 albums, Elvis had also enjoyed many Nr. 1 singles in 1956 and 1957, while Harry had never made it to Nr. 1 with any of the 7″ formats.
That said, Harry’s audience (mature America) was not the single buying public, while Elvis’ target audience (teenage USA) consisted mainly of single buying teens.
 
On the other hand, Harry spent a recordbreaking total of 99 weeks on the Album chart with CALYPSO.
Elvis would not be able to break this record until 5 years later when G.I. Blues left the chart after 111 weeks.

 
 
 
 
 

And the winner is …

RCA Victor!

For having spent 64 weeks (out of 104) in the Nr. 1 position with the 2 biggest sellers in the music business in 1956 and 1957!

Of course there never was a ‘battle’ in the first place.
Rock ‘n’ Roll and Calypso co-existed peacefully together since both genres targetted very different audiences.

 
 
 

Elvis and Harry

 
 
 

212

 
 
 

26 Comments Post a comment
  1. Jim #

    Love the Italian 10″ lp’s.
    They sure were plugging Belafonte in Poplar Tunes!

    April 1, 2013
  2. Hi Jim, thanks for commenting. Cocktail # 8 wasn’t a 10 inch but a regular big one.
    Even though in this day and age it’s getting harder and harder to dig up ‘rare’
    early Elvis releases not, or not often, seen before, there’s some really kool stuff
    lined up for future topics on Echoes… We keep on digging!

    April 2, 2013
  3. Jim Turner #

    My mistake number 3 and 5 were 10″.
    Look forward to some nice rare records from around the globe.

    April 2, 2013
  4. PJM #

    I have the full magazine Tommy Sands vs. Belafonte and Elvis. 1957. New York: The Girl
    Friend-The Boy Friend Corp 1957 66pgs in Fine almost Mint condition. Does anyone know the current grade values?

    April 27, 2013
  5. Hi PJM, thanks for your reply to this topic. In the good old days of collecting rare
    teen-mag titles, it sold for 50-60 US Dollars… Currently on ebay, a very fine copy sold for
    under 30 dollars. Value on most paper items from the 50s have dropped…
    It’s the same with vinyl and shellacs. Of course there are exceptions, but in general
    it all has gone down a bit.

    April 27, 2013
    • PJM #

      Thanks for the prompt reply!

      April 28, 2013
  6. I would like to add, had I been given the chance to buy both above mag titles, while
    I was still collecting, years ago, I would have gladly paid a hundred bucks for
    each of them! I never ever found them for sale during my 30 plus years collecting
    vintage magazines! Screw ebay, these mags are indeed some of the rarest of
    the rare! Great collectors piece, PJM !
    Do you also have the “16” issue in your collection?

    April 28, 2013
    • PJM #

      Hi Ger Rijff,

      Sorry for the major delay. I am looking to sell the mag asap. What would you offer for the Tommy Sands vs. Belafonte and Elvis?

      Paul

      April 12, 2014
    • Israel #

      Harry Belafonte is more than a match for Elvis. Harry was and is one of the very best voices of them all.
      The great Marty Robbins and the greatest voice of them all, Sam Cooke, also did a grand job.

      February 13, 2016
      • Michael #

        What a load of crap! He was no match for Elvis. Elvis changed popular music and culture. All Belafonte did was take an existing musical genre and have some success with it. You obviously haven’t listened to much of Elvis’ extensive repertoire beyond a few of the popular hits. He covered many genres, and is still having No.1 albums to this day. Leaving Elvis aside for a moment (his talent, success, popularity and influence is something that is self evident so doesn’t need defending) you argue that Same Cooke has the greatest voice of all. What? Greater than Caruso, Lanza, Pavarotti? Comparing voices in such a manner is pointless. If you’re going to go down that route then you could argue that Jackie Wilson had a far better voice than Cooke – it certainly had a far greater power and range. Again, it’s a pointless exercise. Many people have great singing voices, Elvis included, yet it takes more than that to change popular music and culture forever. Elvis did that, Belefonte didn’t.

        December 16, 2016
  7. Thank you for such an informative website! I have searched the web over for information on this rare tommy sands vs Belafonte and Elvis magazine you guys are talking about. I also have one in mint condition and was going to sell it but didn’t know what price to put on it. I see one on ebay now listed for $350.00 so I thought I better do my homework. Please email me if you guys find out any new info or if any of your collectors which to pay a good price for it. Thanks! Have a blessed day!

    May 3, 2013
  8. Let’s have a whole section on Daddio Dewey, Quiffy!
    “Get yourself a wheelbarrow full of monkeys, run ’em through the front door and tell ’em Phillips sent ya!”

    May 12, 2013
  9. Josep #

    Thanks, Ger, for sharing these rare images.

    When I started out in this racket, er, business, I had this friend of mine, whom I haven’t seen for ages, who was also an Elvis fan, and whose father had worked in West Germany in the early 60s, and was a huge Belafonte fan. While in Germany, he had access to original US RCA Victor issues of Harry’s records and they were still in his collection by the time his son and I became interested in rock and roll. He used to play his Belafonte collection for us, and I still remember the likes of “Jamaica Farewell”, “Day-O” and “Star-O”. Unfortunately, he hadn’t kept the US Presley issues he had purchased around the same time, so we had to make do with the inner sleeves of Harry’s albums, which featured beautiful colour reproductions of other Victor releases, including some by Elvis.

    A brief glimpse at Elvis Presley fandom long before the days of FTD. For free !

    Thanks again !

    June 21, 2015
  10. Jans #

    Great article !
    Thanks for posting.

    January 9, 2016
  11. Superb job, Bob.
    And thanks for the new added info + pix. Very much appreciated!

    January 9, 2016
  12. Great feature, and the punch-line was superb, thank you.

    January 9, 2016
  13. Alan White #

    Unusual feature, Harry Belafonte’s Jump In The Line is currently used on a TV AD for mobile phones, and was also used in the weird film BeetleJuice.

    January 10, 2016
  14. Judith #

    Apparently missed this first time round, so thanks for the update. Very interesting read!

    January 12, 2016
  15. Craig Philo #

    I was brought up on listening to both. Great article.

    January 17, 2016
  16. Nico Declerck #

    I like this article. It is balanced, well written, based on facts, and both singers are treated very respectfully.

    I wonder what would have happened if RCA would have spread the albums better in time. But wait, oh no … by 1958 and 1959 there would be more competition from the Jim Reeves-albums (also on RCA)!

    Great article, please keep them coming.
    Thanks :-)

    February 4, 2016
  17. Mike Windgren #

    Fantastic read. Thank you!.

    February 8, 2016
  18. Robert van Beek #

    Just love reading articles like this. Very well documented. Wait and see the next comparison.

    April 16, 2016
  19. Judith #

    So today on a hot day in Holland in 2016, I heard this song blaring from a car radio and was immediately reminded of this topic. Such a great song. Some songs are best heard on a car radio!

    August 25, 2016
  20. Guillermo Perez Arguello #

    The charts is one thing, but the output of RCA during those two years favoured Presley, who sold 10 million units in 1956 and another 14 million units in 1957. Also, by mid 1957, when the economic data from 1956 was released, it showed that the sale of RCA radios, transistors, recorders, phonographs and televisons had doubled, tripled and quadrupled, with respect of those sold in 1955, the latter being partially the result of the extraordinary tallies Elvis garnered for at least two of the three networks, yielding in excess of 200 million cumulative viewers for his 12 appearances from late January of 1956 to early January of 1957, three of them hitting a 40 rating or over, with an additional record, still unbeaten, to this day, naemly the 82.6 % share obtained on 9 September 1956, the night of his first appearance at the Ed Sullivan Show. Presley also toured 107 ciities, playing in 289 shows during that period, drawing over a half a million fans to large auditoriums and at least seven stadiums, both in the US and Canada. For all of the above, which is in addition to chart results, RCA owed a lor more to Presley than it did to Harry, in that two year period and obviously, beyond as well.

    March 2, 2017
    • Guillermo Perez Arguello #

      Actually he played in 9 stadiums, eight years before the Beatles played Shea Stadium. These were Sicks Stadium, in Seattle, the most famous in attendance, a 15 year old Jimi Hendrix. The Cotton Cowl, in Dallas, the Gator Bowl, in Floirda, Empire Stadium, in Vancouver, Russwood Park in Memphis, Memorial Stadium in Spokane, WA, Lincoln Bowl in Tacoma, WA Mulnomah Stadium in Portland, OR, and Honolulu Stadium in Hawaii. No other singer in the 1950’s, ALONE played stadiums…

      March 2, 2017
      • Guillermo Perez Arguello #

        Presley was a big fan of Belafonte, and Belafonte, a human rights activist himself, had the following to say about Elvis:
        “Different as our sounds were in 1956, I could see that we were in parallel tracks, Elvis was interpreting one kind of black music, R&B, while I found my inspiration in black folk songs, spirituals and calypso. (A year passed, and while in Las Vegas) Elvis came backstage to say hello and he couldn’t have been more decorous, insisting in calling me Mr. Belafonte. Only later would I learn that he had hung out for years with a lot of black musicians and had come by his style legitimately. (Alas), he performed with such put on flash that over the next years, I noticed, he inspired a whole generation of R&B players who thought they could put that flash on, and become Elvis, too … “

        March 2, 2017

Leave a Reply

You may use basic HTML in your comments. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS